LicenseManager.dev vs Rindkey
Both add license keys to your own Stripe account, including Stripe Managed Payments, and both import your existing Lemon Squeezy keys unchanged. The differences: whether activations come along, how much of your app's license code changes, and whether you also need files delivered.
What each one says it does
As of November 20, 2026, from LicenseManager.dev's own pages (pricing, Lemon Squeezy migration guide, Lemon Squeezy comparison, Managed Payments page) and our own product. Things change, so check their site before you decide.
| LicenseManager.dev | Rindkey | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Licensing service. Doesn't take payments: it creates licenses when Stripe or Paddle says a customer paid. Not a merchant of record itself; works with Paddle, which is. | Fulfillment for your own Stripe account, including Stripe Managed Payments. Doesn't take payments. Not a merchant of record. |
| Payment providers | Stripe (with or without Managed Payments) and Paddle Billing. | Stripe: Checkout, Payment Links and Managed Payments. No Paddle. |
| Price | Free (100 active licenses, 3 products, 10,000 API requests per 30 days). Startup €29/month (1,000 active licenses, 10 products), Standard €99/month (5,000, unlimited products). Yearly €290 / €990. Prices exclude VAT. No cut of sales. | Free (50 active licenses, 1 product, 1 GB of files, no card). Indie $24, Pro $49, Scale $99 per month; yearly gets two months free. First 50 paying customers get 50% off for life. No cut of sales; Stripe's own fees still apply. |
| What counts as active | A license validated by a machine in the last 90 days and not expired. Over a limit you're emailed at 75% and 90%, then get a 7-day grace period. | Keys that aren't expired or disabled. |
| Lemon Squeezy key import | Yes. Keys kept as they are, from a CSV you make with its export script (disabled keys left out, expired ones imported expired). Or email them and they do the import for you, for free. | Yes, self-serve in the dashboard over the Lemon Squeezy API, no script: keys unchanged, activation limits, expiry dates and status. Starts as a dry run. |
| Existing activations | Not imported. Its guide says each license starts with no machine, and each computer takes a place at its first validation with the new version. | Imported with their original Lemon Squeezy instance IDs, so installed copies keep validating and seat counts carry over. |
| Subscriptions Lemon Squeezy moves to Stripe | The import links each key to its new Stripe (or Paddle) subscription through a subscription_id column, so renewals extend the imported license. | Keys from new Stripe sales follow their subscription. Linking imported keys to the subscriptions Lemon Squeezy moves isn't built yet. |
| License checks from your app | Its SDKs (Electron, Tauri, Swift, plus API clients for Go, Python, Ruby, Java, C#, PHP and TypeScript) or one request, POST /v1/products/{productId}/validate-key, with no secret. Machines are identified by fingerprint. The new version passes the stored Lemon Squeezy key once, silently. | Lemon Squeezy-compatible /v1/licenses/activate|validate|deactivate: same params, JSON and errors. Change the base URL. Public, so your shipped app calls it without a secret. |
| Offline checks | Ed25519-signed tokens verified in your app. | Ed25519-signed offline-grace tokens (1 to 30 days). |
| File downloads | No file hosting (its own comparison page says so). | Signed file downloads that expire. The import can copy your Lemon Squeezy files too. |
| Customer portal | Keys, machines (free a place), cancel for a refund, manage the subscription. | Keys, activations (self-serve deactivate) and downloads. |
| Refunds made in Stripe | Its guide says a refund in Stripe doesn't change the license: you cancel or expire it yourself. | A full refund disables the key by default. You can switch to any refund, or never. |
| Releases and updates | Releases and update checks, including updates for a limited time (customers keep the versions released while their license was valid). | No update or release endpoint yet. |
Same keys, different first launch
When a customer activates your app, Lemon Squeezy stores that seat as an instance ID, and your app usually saves it. LicenseManager.dev's guide says activations aren't imported: each license starts with no machine, and each computer takes a seat at its first validation with the new version. Its SDK passes the stored key once, silently, so customers don't retype it.
Rindkey imports each activation with its original instance ID. Your next release keeps calling validate with the instance ID it already stored, just at rindkey.com/v1/licenses/…, and seat counts carry over.
When LicenseManager may suit you better
- You sell through Paddle, or plan to. LicenseManager.dev connects Paddle Billing. Rindkey is Stripe-only.
- You want native desktop SDKs with machine fingerprinting, node locking against key sharing, clock-tampering detection and trials that survive reinstalls. Rindkey has none of that. It's an HTTP API.
- You gate updates by license period and want releases and update checks built in. Rindkey has no update endpoint yet.
- You sold subscription licenses and want imported keys linked to the subscriptions Lemon Squeezy moves to Stripe. LicenseManager.dev's import does this. Rindkey's doesn't yet.
- You'd rather have someone else run the import. LicenseManager.dev offers to do it for free. Rindkey's import is self-serve.
- You need team seats, roles, two-factor sign-in, an audit log and analytics, all listed on its pricing page.
Rindkey suits you if you deliver files as well as keys, want existing activations to keep working with the instance IDs your app already stored, or don't want to adopt a new SDK: change one base URL in your next release.
Rindkey is new, and so is its Lemon Squeezy importer. It's built and tested against Lemon Squeezy's documented API, but it hasn't been run on a real store yet. So start with the free dry run: it shows how many keys, activations and files would come across before anything is written.
Rindkey isn't affiliated with LicenseManager.dev or Lemon Squeezy. Spot something out of date? Email hello@rindkey.com and we'll fix it.
See what your store needs before you move
The readiness check is free and read-only. It counts your products, keys by status, activations, files and renewing subscriptions. Your Lemon Squeezy API key is used in memory for one request and never stored.