Comparison

Lemon Squeezy alternatives: where to move your store, keys and files

Lemon Squeezy stops processing payments on March 31, 2027 (132 days from today). Most guides compare fees. This one also covers the part that decides whether your existing customers get locked out: license keys, activations and file downloads.

The deadline

What Lemon Squeezy is asking you to do

  • New store sign-ups closed on November 16, 2026. Payments stop on March 31, 2027, including subscription renewals, and Lemon Squeezy says it won't extend that date.
  • Its migration tooling to Stripe Managed Payments opens on December 2, 2026. Lemon Squeezy says a move takes 4 to 8 weeks and recommends starting by mid-January 2027.
  • Managed Payments, the route Lemon Squeezy recommends, doesn't deliver files, download links or license keys. Lemon Squeezy's own guide says you need a separate fulfillment tool or your own build. It also warns that customers may lose access to their keys, files and links after March 31 if you haven't moved them.
  • Checkout links, embeds, API calls and webhooks don't redirect. PayPal subscriptions can't move to any provider, and Managed Payments doesn't take PayPal.

So there are really two decisions. Who takes your payments, and who delivers what customers bought: keys, activations, files and a page where they find them. Some options do both. Some do one.

Short answer

Which alternative fits your store

If you…Look at firstWhy
Ship a desktop app, plugin or extension that calls the Lemon Squeezy License API, and your business can use Managed PaymentsStripe Managed Payments + RindkeyLemon Squeezy's own tooling moves your card subscriptions to Stripe. Rindkey imports your keys and activations with their original instance IDs, so installed copies keep validating after you change one base URL.
Sell a WordPress plugin with site activationsStripe Managed Payments + RindkeyEach site saved its instance ID in its options. Rindkey keeps those IDs, so sites keep getting updates without re-activating. See the WordPress guide.
Need a merchant of record outside Stripe and want your old key strings to keep workingDodo PaymentsIts CLI imports Lemon Squeezy keys with limits and expiry dates. Activations don't come over, so every device activates again.
Need PayPal at checkoutPaddle or Dodo PaymentsManaged Payments, Polar and Creem don't take PayPal. Paddle's checkout and Dodo's pricing list it. Existing PayPal subscribers still have to buy again wherever you go.
Run subscription SaaS with no keys or downloadsStripe Managed Payments or PaddleLemon Squeezy's tooling moves eligible card subscriptions to Managed Payments. Paddle offers assisted migration to eligible stores. You don't need a fulfillment tool.
Sell ebooks, templates or courses and want the simplest storefrontGumroadA merchant of record with hosting, keys and a marketplace. It's the most expensive per sale here (10% + 50¢), and it can't import keys.
Need floating, metered or offline licensing and have engineers to wire itKeygenA licensing API with every license type. You connect payments yourself. No Lemon Squeezy importer, but its API accepts a key you supply, so you can script the import.

The readiness check tells you which row you're in. It counts your products, keys by status, activations, files and renewing subscriptions in a few seconds. Check your store →

Side by side

What each option does about keys, activations and files

As of November 2026, from each vendor's own pricing, docs and migration pages (Lemon Squeezy migration, Stripe Managed Payments, Polar, Creem, Dodo Payments, Paddle, Gumroad, LicenseManager.dev, Keyplar, Keygen). Things change, so check their sites before you decide. Rindkey isn't affiliated with any of them or with Lemon Squeezy.

Payments and fees

What it isPublished feesLemon Squeezy subscriptionsPayPal
Stripe Managed PaymentsStripe's merchant of record3.5% per transaction plus Stripe processing fees. Lemon Squeezy migrants get 1.5% through Dec 1, 2027.Moved by Lemon Squeezy's tooling (eligible card subscriptions, at least 14 days' notice to customers)No
Rindkey (with Stripe or Managed Payments)Fulfillment on your own Stripe. Not a merchant of record.Free (50 active licenses), then $24 / $49 / $99 a month. No cut of sales; Stripe's fees still apply.Stay on Stripe via Lemon Squeezy's tooling. Rindkey follows subscription status.What your Stripe setup offers
PolarMerchant of recordStarter 5% + 50¢. Pro $20/mo + 3.8% + 40¢, Growth $100/mo + 3.6% + 35¢, Scale $400/mo + 3.4% + 30¢. +1.5% for non-US cards, plus payout fees."In conversation with Lemon Squeezy." Recommends waiting before you pick a destination.Not yet
CreemMerchant of record3.9% + 40¢, no monthly fee. First month at 0 fees for Lemon Squeezy merchants.Each subscriber checks out again on Creem. A direct import is "in development".No
Dodo PaymentsMerchant of record4% + 40¢ (US cards). +1.5% international, +0.5% subscriptions, +3% PayPal.The CLI doesn't move subscriptions. Dodo has a separate subscription migration process.Yes (+3%)
PaddleMerchant of record5% + 50¢ per checkout transactionPaddle-assisted migration for eligible card subscriptions, or customer-ledYes
GumroadMerchant of record and marketplace10% + 50¢ direct, 30% via DiscoverNo import documentedNot stated on its pricing page
LicenseManager.devLicensing on your Stripe or PaddleFree (100 active licenses), €29 / €99 a monthLinks imported keys to subscriptions Lemon Squeezy moved to Stripen/a
KeyplarDelivery and portal on your Stripe$29 / $79 a month, 14-day trial, card at signupImports subscription historyn/a
KeygenLicensing APIFree Dev tier (100 active users). Paid tiers on their pricing page.n/an/a

Fulfillment (the part that locks customers out if it goes wrong)

Issues license keysKeeps existing Lemon Squeezy keysKeeps activations (instance IDs)Your app's license codeFile downloadsCustomer page for keys and files
Stripe Managed PaymentsNoNoNon/aNoLink shows orders and subscriptions only
RindkeyYesYes, unchanged, with limits, expiry and statusYes, original instance IDsSame endpoints and JSON as Lemon Squeezy. Change the base URL. No secret in the app.Yes, signed links that expireYes
PolarYesNot yet ("looking into a way")NoRewrite: own endpoints with your organization IDYes, up to 10 GB per fileYes
CreemYesNo, issues new keysNoRewrite, and calls need your API key in a headerYes, expiring linksYes
Dodo PaymentsYesYes, via CLI (active keys only)No, customers re-activateRewrite: public endpoints, different paramsYesYes (keys, invoices, subscriptions)
PaddleNoNo. Paddle says keys and files are yours to rebuild.NoYou build itNoPast purchases and invoices
GumroadYesNo, can't import keysNoRewrite to Gumroad's verify APIYesReceipt and download page
LicenseManager.devYesYes, free done-for-you importNo, per its guideIts SDKs or validate endpointNoYes
KeyplarYesYes, "exactly as they are"Not statedRewrite: server-side API keyYesYes
KeygenYesNot documented, but you can create licenses with your own key stringsNot documentedRewrite to Keygen's APIPaid tiers (Distribution API)Not documented
The part most guides skip

Moving the keys isn't the whole job

When a customer activates your app or plugin, Lemon Squeezy creates an instance and your app usually saves its ID. After the move, the new provider has to recognize that ID, or every installed copy is checking against nothing.

  1. 01
    New keys.Every past buyer gets a new key and enters it. This is the Polar (today), Creem, Gumroad and Paddle path.
  2. 02
    Same keys, fresh activations.Old keys work, but each device or site activates again. LicenseManager.dev's guide says activations aren't imported, and Dodo says customers must re-activate. Seats are free at first, so a key with a limit of 2 can end up on 2 new machines plus the old ones that never re-checked.
  3. 03
    Same keys, same activations.Installed copies keep validating with the instance ID they already stored. This is what Rindkey's import does.

Whichever you pick, ship the app update well before March 31. What happens to Lemon Squeezy's License API after that date isn't documented, so plan as if it stops.

Honest fit

When Stripe + Rindkey is the right call, and when it isn't

Rindkey suits you if:

  • Your business can use Stripe Managed Payments (or you'll handle tax on plain Stripe), so Lemon Squeezy's own tooling moves your subscriptions.
  • You ship software that calls the Lemon Squeezy License API, and you want existing customers to stay activated without doing anything.
  • You deliver files and want one portal for keys, seat resets and downloads.

Look elsewhere if:

  • Managed Payments doesn't support your country and you need a merchant of record. Rindkey doesn't take payments; look at Polar, Creem, Dodo or Paddle.
  • You need PayPal, a storefront, affiliates or a checkout overlay. Rindkey has none of these.
  • You need GitHub repo access (Keyplar), usage quotas per key (Polar), native desktop SDKs (LicenseManager.dev) or floating licenses (Keygen).
Where our importer stands

Rindkey is new, and so is its Lemon Squeezy importer. It's built and tested against Lemon Squeezy's documented API, but it hasn't been run on a real store yet. So start with the free dry run: it shows how many keys, activations and files would come across before anything is written.

How to migrate Lemon Squeezy license keys · License API compatibility · Pricing

Questions

Common questions

What is the best Lemon Squeezy alternative?

It depends on two things: whether your business can use Stripe Managed Payments, and whether you sell license keys or files. If you can use Managed Payments and sell nothing to fulfill, Managed Payments alone is the shortest path, since Lemon Squeezy's tooling moves your subscriptions. If you sell keys or files, pair it with a fulfillment tool, or pick a merchant of record that has them built in (Polar, Creem, Dodo).

Can I keep my existing Lemon Squeezy license keys?

With some tools. Rindkey, LicenseManager.dev, Keyplar and Dodo Payments say they import existing keys unchanged. Polar says it's looking into it. Creem and Gumroad issue new keys. LicenseManager.dev's guide says activations aren't imported, and Dodo says customers must re-activate. Of the tools we checked, Rindkey is the only one that documents keeping activations with their original instance IDs.

Does Stripe Managed Payments do license keys or file downloads?

No. Lemon Squeezy's comparison page lists digital fulfillment and license keys as not included, and says to connect a fulfillment or licensing app or build your own with Stripe webhooks.

Is there a Lemon Squeezy alternative with PayPal?

Paddle and Dodo Payments list PayPal. Stripe Managed Payments, Polar and Creem don't take it. Wherever you go, Lemon Squeezy can't move PayPal subscriptions, so those customers have to subscribe again with another payment method.

What happens to my customers' downloads after March 31, 2027?

Lemon Squeezy says customers may lose access to their license keys, files and links if you haven't moved them by then. Move your files and order history to the new tool before the deadline, and tell customers where their new download page is.

How long does a Lemon Squeezy migration take?

Lemon Squeezy says 4 to 8 weeks end to end, and recommends starting no later than mid-January 2027. Its tooling for Managed Payments opens December 2, 2026. You can check your store and do a dry-run key import before then.

Find out which alternative your store needs

The readiness check is free and read-only. It counts your products, keys by status, activations, files and renewing subscriptions, then tells you what breaks when Lemon Squeezy stops. Your API key is used in memory for one request and never stored.

Rindkey isn't affiliated with Lemon Squeezy, Stripe or any vendor named here. Spot something out of date? Email hello@rindkey.com and we'll fix it.