Polar vs Rindkey
Polar is a merchant of record with license keys built in. Rindkey keeps you on your own Stripe account and moves your existing Lemon Squeezy keys and activations. Here's where each one stands today.
What each one says it does
As of November 2026, from Polar's own pages (Lemon Squeezy migration page, fees, license keys docs) and our own product. Things change, so check their site before you decide.
| Polar | Rindkey | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Merchant of record. Polar is the seller, handles tax and runs checkout. | Fulfillment for your own Stripe account, including Stripe Managed Payments. Not a merchant of record. |
| Price | Free Starter plan at 5% + 50¢ per sale. Pro $20/month (3.8% + 40¢), Growth $100/month (3.6% + 35¢), Scale $400/month (3.4% + 30¢). +1.5% for non-US cards, plus payout fees. | Free to start (50 active licenses, no card). Indie $24, Pro $49, Scale $99 per month. No cut of your sales; Stripe's own fees still apply. |
| Existing Lemon Squeezy keys | Not yet. Its migration page says it's "looking into a way" to bring existing keys over unchanged. | Yes: keys (unchanged), activation limits, expiry dates, status, activations with their original instance IDs, and files. |
| Existing subscribers | Says it's in conversation with Lemon Squeezy about taking over subscriptions, and recommends waiting before you pick a destination. | Stay on Stripe: Lemon Squeezy's own tooling moves eligible subscriptions to Stripe Managed Payments. Rindkey issues keys on new Stripe sales and follows subscription status. |
| License checks from your app | Its own endpoints (/v1/customer-portal/license-keys/activate, validate) with your organization ID and a label, so Lemon Squeezy code needs rewriting. | Lemon Squeezy-compatible /v1/licenses/activate|validate|deactivate: same params, JSON and errors. Public, so your shipped app calls it without a secret. |
| License key features | Prefixes, expiry, activation limits, usage quotas, custom validation conditions, customer self-deactivation and key rotation. | Expiry, activation limits, status, customer self-deactivation in the portal, offline-grace signed tokens (1 to 30 days). |
| Files and portal | File download benefit and a customer portal. | Signed, expiring file downloads and a customer portal. |
A new checkout, or fulfillment for the one you keep
Polar is a merchant of record: it becomes the seller, handles sales tax and runs the checkout, and its license keys come with that. Moving there means moving your payments too.
Rindkey doesn't take payments. It sits behind your own Stripe account (including Stripe Managed Payments, the route Lemon Squeezy recommends), issues keys and files when Stripe says someone paid, and brings your Lemon Squeezy keys and activations along.
When Polar may suit you better
- You'd rather hand sales tax to a merchant of record other than Stripe, and you're fine with per-sale fees.
- You're starting fresh: new keys for new customers are OK, and you don't need old activations carried over.
- You want per-key usage quotas (for example, metered API credits). Polar has them. Rindkey doesn't.
Rindkey suits you if you ship a desktop app, plugin or extension that calls the Lemon Squeezy License API directly, you're moving payments to Stripe, and you want existing customers to stay activated without doing anything.
Rindkey isn't affiliated with Polar or Lemon Squeezy. Spot something out of date? Email hello@rindkey.com and we'll fix it.
See what your store needs before you move
The readiness check is free and read-only. Your Lemon Squeezy API key is used in memory for one request and never stored.